Editors Picks

Tampilkan postingan dengan label South China Sea. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label South China Sea. Tampilkan semua postingan

Rabu, 10 Agustus 2016

China's Credibility at Stake



China's protest and disappointment over the rejection of its claim in a territorial dispute in the South China Sea poses a dilemma for Beijing.

According to international and defense analysts, China on one hand wants to ignite the spirit of nationalism in its citizens, but on the other hand needs to expand its influence and diplomatic ambitions.

The rejection of the claim by the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague, the Netherlands, is a major diplomatic defeat for China, a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council.

This occurred a few decades ago when the country decided to join the World Trade Organization (WTO) and became the second largest country in terms of economy.
An analyst on China from the International Crisis Group, Yanmei Xie, said China's ambitions to achieve a greater level of global diplomacy had become uncertain.

China is now at a point where it wants to emerge as a leader in international institutions. However, its credibility will be tarnished if it goes against international law and international institutions. With its latest stance of denouncing the South China Sea territorial claims, the country will be seen as showing a lack of impartiality.

Firmly rejected
The Chinese government has strongly rejected the decision of the International Court of Arbitration. In fact, China's ambassador to the UN, Cui Tiankai, said the ruling could lead to conflict. "It will clearly fuel the conflict and even confrontation," Cui said in Washington.

In Jakarta, the chairman of the Chinese government's Public Diplomacy Consultation, Chen Shiqiu, said that the International Court of Arbitration had not respected the facts and history as the essence of the dispute between China and the Philippines in the South China Sea. The court also hurt China's stance over its areas in the South China Sea.

Chen, who was China's ambassador to Indonesia from 1998-2002, said he was a little surprised by the Indonesian government's statement on the court ruling. Given the dispute was only between China and the Philippines and Indonesia was not a claimant state, he had hoped Indonesia's view of the problem would be more objective. When asked about the Natuna Sea, Chen referred to the meeting of China's and Indonesia's foreign ministers in 1995.

"At that time, China unveiled its sovereignty claim over the territory in the South China Sea. Indonesia did not express its opposition. That means Indonesia confirmed its position as a non-claimant country," Chen said.

China's deputy foreign minister, Liu Zhenmin, said in Beijing that his country could impose an air defense identification zone (ADIZ) over its territorial waters if it felt threatened. If the ADIZ was put in place, both civil and military aircraft would have to notify the Chinese military authorities of their identity and report a flight plan to obtain permission to cross over designated areas.

"Whether we need to impose this on the South China Sea depends on the level of threat that we receive," Liu said. As quoted by the BBC, Liu expected all countries to work with China to safeguard peace and stability in the South China Sea and would not let the region become a source of war.

Like China, Taiwan also rejected the court's ruling. With its stance against the court's decision on China's claims, Taiwanese authorities will continue to send aircraft and patrol vessels to the South China Sea.

Meanwhile, Xinhua news agency reported that two of China's civil aircraft on Wednesday morning had landed on two new runways at Mischief Reef and Subi Reef. The two coral reef atolls in the Spratly Island, which had been reclaimed by China, are now controlled by Beijing.

Both aircraft were then flown back to Hainan province in southern China. However, Xinhua did not clarify whether the two planes had landed on the same island or on two islands.

Restraint
The Philippine government chose not to be too euphoric over the court's decision. Foreign Minister Perfecto Yasay Jr. asked all parties for restraint. "In matters such as this, we cannot make provocative statements. We ask all parties, including China, to exercise restraint and remain calm," Perfecto said.

Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte repeatedly stated his wish to improve diplomatic relations with China. He wants to encourage economic development, especially infrastructure, to develop the southern part of the country.

Source Kompas, Thursday, July 14, 2016

Indonesia, South China Sea after PCA Ruling



Since the end of the 1980s, there has been concern about the future surrounding the overlap of claims in the South China Sea.

Though not a claimant, Indonesia will find it hard to turn its back on developments related to the South China Sea. Now, a few years after China has risen and become increasingly assertive in expressing its claim, the concern has become a reality. The concern is focused on the increasing regional tension.

The scope of the potential tension is not just regional, considering extra-regional powers - in this case the US - will not sit quietly watching China's actions. The US has sent its Seventh Fleet warship to the South China Sea, while a P-8 Poseidonreconnaissance aircraft and a B-52 strategic bomber aircraft have also flown to the South China Sea with the pretext of guarding navigation freedom in the area. The development of islands with numerous facilities cannot be accepted by other claimants.

Amid the increasingly fierce war of claims, the Philippines, as one of the claimants, filed an objection at the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in 2013. On Tuesday (12/7), the court ruled against China's claim on the South China Sea, which is marked by a nine-dash line. The decision was based on the consideration that China's claim did not have any legal basis. The claim, which is based on China's historic rights, fell through because it was not in line with exclusive economic zones as determined by the United Nations.

Following the issuance of the court ruling, a number of countries, especially the Philippines, which feels its area is being breached by China, greeted it with delight. The official stance of the Indonesian government was announced by the foreign minister, who called on all parties to respect the court ruling and prioritize peace. The ministry also urged all parties to maintain stability, practice self-restraint and respect international law, particularly the UN Convention on the 1982 Law of the Sea.
In contrast, China has responded to the court ruling by stating that it will not accept it. Unlike the statement of the court that called the ruling binding (though it does not have the power to apply it), China called the ruling empty and said it does not have binding power.

What is the stance of ASEAN countries in response to China's insistence? Experience from the ASEAN Summit in Phnom Penh in 2012, as well as a special ASEAN-China meeting in Yuxi in June 2016, shows that the response to the South China Sea issue within ASEAN is also problematic.

This is where Indonesia needs to have more bargaining power to negotiate with China, whether for its own interests or to defend the interests of ASEAN countries that are also claimants to the South China Sea.

Source Kompas, Thursday, July 14, 2016

ASEAN and the South China Sea



Tuesday, July 12, 2016, is an important day for ASEAN because the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) issued a legal edict on the South China Sea. Why is this considered important? The solidity of ASEAN will be tested in responding to this most recent development in the South China Sea.

Facts show that ASEAN failed to issue a joint statement on the South China Sea at the ASEAN Summit in July 2012 in Phnom Penh. In this case, Cambodia, as the ASEAN chair and ASEAN Summit host, played an important role in this failure. This happened because of China's intensive approach toward Cambodia.

A similar incident happened again in the ASEAN-China Special Meeting in Yuxi, Junnan province, held from June 13 to 14. Laos, the new ASEAN chair, and Cambodia, objected to the content of the press communiqué on the South China Sea, thus the document was withdrawn again. This difference in attitude between ASEAN member countries could diminish the concept of ASEAN's centrality in the Southeast Asian region, which is positioned on the platform of the integrity of ASEAN's stance. Therefore, how Laos, as ASEAN chair, handles and manages the ASEAN position in response to the PCA decision, has attracted a lot of global attention.

PCA decision
Whatever decision arrived at by the PCA, presided over by Judge Thomas A Mensh and assisted by four other judges, would certainly be rejected by China. Since its inception, China has shown its basic stance. A verbal note sent by China to the PCA on Aug. 1, 2013, stated that the PCA did not have jurisdiction over problems in the South China Sea and China would reject its decision.

Ouyang Yujing, director general of border and maritime affairs issues, clarified and explained explicitly that Chinese sovereignty over the islands, coral reefs and marine areas in the South China Sea was not determined by an international organization. Therefore, according to Yujing, the PCA had no right to issue any legal edict on the issue of sovereignty and had no right to decide the extent of China's maritime rights.

Meanwhile, Western countries, such as the UK and the US, have urged China to respect and comply with the PCA ruling. China's rejection of the PCA's legal ruling is considered able to undermine the credibility of UNCLOS. Indeed, as admitted by Paul Reichler, a lawyer for the Philippines at the PCA, the PCA is not as strong as the International Court of Justice (ICJ), which has the authority to enforce its legal decisions.

Unlike the ICJ, the PCA does not have the authority set out in Article 94 of the UN Charter, which gives the right to the party being harmed by other parties that are not complying with the court's decision to take the matter to the UN Security Council (UNSC). In turn, the UNSC provides a recommendation or takes the steps necessary to ensure the implementation of the court's decision.

Paul Rechler believes that rising international pressure on China will be able to soften its very stiff stance. Therefore, the reactions of countries other than those in dispute are important because they can have a significant influence.

Meanwhile, the position of China in terms of the PCA is very firm and inflexible. China states that the PCA does not work in accordance with the law and is tarnished by illogical and erroneous matters in implementing evidence, law and procedures. In a telephone conversation with US Secretary of State John Kerry, which was leaked to Beijing People's Daily, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi said that any PCA decision that disregarded the law and facts would itself be not legally binding.

Military exercises
While statements continue to be exchanged by the parties in dispute over the South China Sea, the US and the Philippines are conducting joint military exercises around the Spratly Islands. Several destroyers from the US Seventh Asia Pacific Fleet were moved closer to the Spratly Islands. The US-Philippine joint exercise has been criticized by the Chinese mass media as an effort to militarize the Southeast Asian region inspired by a Cold War mentality.

In response, China is also conducting war games around the Paracel Islands, deploying numbers of war ships to demonstrate its military strength. If this continues, it will exacerbate Sino-American rivalry in Asia, which would have a wider tactical and strategic impact. If this is not properly managed, the situation could change from a fight over legal arguments about the South China Sea into a calculation of military capabilities, which would be dangerous.

China could, at some time, announce an air defense identification zone (ADIZ) over the South China Sea, as has been carried out in the skies over the East China Sea. Or it could build a military base on one of the islands in the South China Sea, which would exacerbate the situation.

The potential tensions in Southeast Asia post-July 12, 2016, according to Hugh White from the Australian National University, would be determined by several things. First, China's willpower to exert its influence and to what extent China was willing to damage the political, security, social, cultural and military landscape that had been organized in Southeast Asia. Second, the willpower of the US in its response to China's determination to play in the Southeast Asian theater. And third, how ASEAN responded to the PCA's legal ruling.

For ASEAN, the problem of the South China Sea is not new. Fourteen years ago, ASEAN succeeded in announcing the ASEAN 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea (DOC). Despite many criticisms, the DOC has been binding on all parties involved in South China Sea issues, both ASEAN member countries and China, for a set of principles that have become a solid basis for future agreements, such as the willingness to negotiate the Code of Conducts in the South China Sea.

The role of ASEAN
For ASEAN, the South China Sea has a strategic factor. Aside from being a major global economy and energy shipping route, it also provides the sea lanes between the Southeast Asian islands. Therefore, the security and stability of the South China Sea not only constitutes a regional need but is also essential for sustainable development in the region.

The PCA decision to issue a legal ruling on the South China Sea is a challenge for ASEAN. Will ASEAN be able to mobilize its collective agreement to act firmly on the PCA decision? Can the collective agreement achieved in Sunnylands, in February 2016, be repeated as an assertive stance by ASEAN? Or will ASEAN need to move a step backward from an agreement that has already been achieved? Should ASEAN issue a collective statement in line with China's desires? Or is ASEAN ready to meet China's demand to issue no statement at all?

These questions need to be answered by ASEAN to eliminate doubts over its position on the South China Sea. Indeed, not all members of ASEAN are claimant states, only Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia and Brunei Darussalam. The other six countries can take the initiative to find solutions that emphasize a peaceful resolution. The responsibility of Laos as ASEAN chair is significant in leading to a collective agreement.

Nevertheless, there are specific factors about Laos. First, Laos is a land-locked state so its approach on maritime issues can be questioned. Second, China is the biggest foreign investment country in Laos and its major trading partner. Third, this year is the 25th anniversary of the ASEAN-China Partnership Dialogue. As ASEAN chair, Laos is trying to successfully commemorate this anniversary. And fourth, US President Barack Obama will hold a bilateral visit to Vientiane at the end of 2016. This will generate great interest in improving relations between the two countries.

The unity and integrity of ASEAN is a major key for ASEAN maneuvers post-July 12, 2016. ASEAN unity will more or less depend on the ability of Laos, as ASEAN chair, to maintain balance and negotiate the interests of big countries in the South China Sea. Nonetheless, there is still an opportunity for Indonesia, as the largest country in ASEAN, to play its role in encouraging the resurgence of ASEAN centrality. As there has been a change in the Philippine's national leadership, Indonesia has the opportunity to encourage a meeting between Chinese president Xi Jinping and the president of the Philippines, Rodrigo Duterte, to conduct a dialog in search of a deal. Rather than being actively involved in any confrontational conflict, it is better for ASEAN to encourage the parties in dispute to conduct a dialogue and cooperate so that it can guarantee the ongoing security and stability of Southeast Asia.

by Makarim Wibisono
source Kompas, Wednesday, July 13, 2016