Editors Picks

Tampilkan postingan dengan label economic growth. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label economic growth. Tampilkan semua postingan

Kamis, 28 Juli 2016

Reaching an Eligible Investment Status



International credit rating agency Standard & Poor's, which had changed its name to S&P Global Ratings in April, announced on June 1 that the rating of Indonesia's debts was to be maintained at the BB+ level for the long term and at B for the short them.

BB+ means that the Indonesian government as a debtor has sufficient ability to pay its debts, while B means the obligation to pay debts has a high risk, or there is a possibility it will be unable to pay. The decision on the rating by S&P was based on the finding that the country's fiscal performance has not improved because the structural problems indicate, among other things, the failure of the government to achieve its tax revenue target in 2015 - specifically only collecting 81.5 percent of Rp 1.29 quadrillion.

Besides that, the budget deficit is predicted to expand by an average of 3 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) over the 2016 to 2019 period. Therefore, Indonesia failed to obtain the investment grade status from S&P that was expected by the government of President Joko "Jokowi" Widodo and businesses that were intending to invest in Indonesia.

The highest ratings of AAA, AA+, A, and A- that are given by S&P are expected by securities-issuing countries that are well able to repay the state securities. The ratings of AA+, A or A- help the securities-issuing countries to gain access to the international capital market. International investors and creditors have confidence when investing in countries with A ratings.

From this perspective, the disappointment of the Jokowi government with the S&P evaluation is understandable because the rating given by S&P may have made it difficult for Indonesia to get long-term loans with low interest rates.

Criteria for the rating
What actually are the criteria used by credit rating companies like S&P and Moody's to determine their ratings? Richard Cantor and Frank Packer in their study on "Determinants and Impact of Sovereign Credit Ratings" identify them as follows.

First is the income per capita. The greater the tax potential tax base of the borrower country, the greater the ability of the government to repay its debts. This variable represents the level of political stability and other important factors.

Second is the growth of GDP. A relatively high economic growth rate indicates the existing debt burden of the state will be easier to serve.

Third is inflation. High inflation indicates a structural problem in the government's finances. When the government seems incapable and does not want to cover the existing budget through taxes and securities, it has to choose inflationary financing. Public dissatisfaction over inflation could lead to political instability.

Fourth is fiscal balance. A large budget deficit absorbs domestic private savings and indicates the government does not have the ability and the will to collect taxes from its citizens to cover the existing budget or to pay its debts.

Fifth is the external balance. A large current-account deficit shows the public and private sectors are heavily dependent on foreign funds, which will eventually become intolerable.

Sixth is the level of economic development that is marked by the rise of per capita income and industrialization in the relevant country.

Seventh is a history of debt default. A country that fails to pay its debts is widely perceived as a country with a high debt risk.

According to Cantor and Packer, six of the factors play an important role to determine the country's security rating, namely income per capita, growth of GDP, inflation, external debts, the level of economic development and the history of debt default. A high per capita income, namely US$24,000 and upwards, a low inflation and external debt and a high level of economic development have become reasons to give the rating of AA/Aa to state securities. Meanwhile, a history of debt default limits the state debt rating to Baa/BBB, or below it, which means the ability to pay is adequate. If the systematic linkages between the rating and the fiscal policy or current-account deficits are not found, that is possibly because of an endogeneity problem.

Solutions
Observing the determinants of the credit ratings mentioned above, apparently the Indonesian government is still far behind and has to work harder to reach the investment grade rating from S&P. How then does the Indonesian nation and state address this reality?

First, we must acknowledge that the credit rating agents, among others Moody's, S&P and Fitch, have the role of giving information regarding economic and political risks and even legal issues to international financiers interested in buying debentures or other securities issued by a country. Therefore, the investment grade status given by them to a country greatly affects the international capital market. The credit ratings they issue can be said to represent the international capital market's view.

Second, it is worth criticizing the objectivity of the credit ratings issued by the credit rating agencies. As reported, the big credit rating agents like S&P, Moody's and Fitch are subsidiaries of large-scale investment banks and other commercial companies so that their objectivity is doubtful. Moreover, the fact that the credit rating industry is dominated by Moody's, S&P and Fitch reveals an oligopolistic character that invites public suspicion.

Academics, researchers, politicians and journalists believe the credit rating agencies have great responsibility for any global financial crisis. According to the US Congress, the credit rating agencies, including the investment banks, were primarily responsible for inflating real estate companies, which was followed by the collapse of the financial markets that caused a global recession.

Third, the credit rating agencies actually are part of an international market apparatus network that is laden with neo-liberal ideology. Behind it firmly stands large capital strength that limits the state's interventionist role and defeats national economic policy, even - up to a certain level - beating democracy for the sake of fulfilling the will of the market.

We have witnessed many cases when heads of state tried hard to adjust their national economic policies to the market's priorities, while leaving behind the objectives of their national development. In order to face the trap of the international market currents and the neo-liberalism ideology, we as a nation and state have to be consistent in pursuing the achievement of our national goals, namely poverty alleviation by using measurements in line with the value and dignity of human beings, redistribution of resources as a way to cope with economic and social disparities, protection of human rights and the environment and growth and political stability for the welfare of the entire people.

In order to realize it, consistency of national policy is needed to carry out the mandate of the Constitution, namely the Preamble and Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution.

by Abdul Hakim Garuda Nusantara
source Kompas, Thusrday, June 30, 2016 
Indonesian version can be read here

Rabu, 27 Juli 2016

Shortcut to 7 Percent Growth



An economic policy should ideally focus on maintaining the continuity of development, not on pursuing short-term economic growth targets.

The Joko "Jokowi" Widodo government has started its term with an economic growth target of 7 percent by 2017, as stated in the National Mid-Term Development Plan (RPJMN). Construction of large-scale infrastructure is being used as the backbone to reach such a target.

One-and-a-half years after Jokowi's "Kabinet Kerja" (Working Cabinet) was formed, rising momentum for infrastructure development can increasingly be seen. However, the Central Statistics Agency (BPS) recorded that the economy grew only 4.9 percent in the first quarter of this year, along with the relatively weak purchasing power and growth of private investment. This figure was even lower than the assumed 5.3 percent as mentioned in the 2016 State Budget.

Reasonable growth
The mishitting economic performance has created a feeling of disappointment for various levels of the government. The policy makers now must think harder and find "breakthrough" ideas to boost the economy.

Such a reaction is quite reasonable. Every year, the number of Indonesian people entering the labor force is 2 to 3 million. Weak economic growth affects job creation in the formal sector (licensed businesses having permanent workers), which potentially can raise the unemployment rate.

Nevertheless, it is also better for us to understand the condition of the world economy, which is currently sluggish, and the risks if domestic policy is forced to pursue short-term targets. Hence, several factors should be kept in mind before forming an expectation of Indonesia's economic performance.

First, Indonesia is currently facing shrinking exports of its raw commodities. From January to April, commodity exports such as coal, oil palm and rubber shrank by 15 to 30 percent compared to the previous year. For the whole of this year, the amount of foreign exchange that could be lost from these commodities could reach US$7 billion, or equivalent to Rp 95 trillion. Such a revenue loss could spread like a virus to other supporting sectors, such as industries providing heavy equipment, transport and banking services.

Second, even though the state budget allocation for energy subsidies had already diverted to infrastructure from 2014, government spending has not yet shown significant increases. This is due to the falling revenues from natural resources and trade taxes. Even last year, government spending (not including the burden of debt interests) did not increase when compared to 2014. Only this year has there been an increase, specifically as of May with about Rp 67 trillion compared to the previous year. However, this too is financed by additional debt, so the government should be cautious in not surpassing the state budget's deficit limit.

Third, many sectors still have excessive production capacities. Do not forget that Indonesia received its peak of foreign investment flows in 2011 to 2013. In that period new factories were built, thereby raising the capacity of various industries, starting from food and beverage, iron, to automotive and machinery.

Subsequently, entering 2014, exports fell, the rupiah weakened and sales growth in various sectors started to decline. The turnover of public companies weakened after previously growing at 10 to 15 percent per annum, has now tumbled to at most 5 percent down to zero growth. As a result, when previously 30-percent capacity could be utilized in 2 to 3 years, it now takes twice as long.

It is better for us to ask again what kind of economic growth is ideal for Indonesia? With the Chinese economy weakening, the heyday era of raw commodity exports for Indonesia appears to have passed. Domestic economic growth can no longer rely on household consumption, but has to be based on exports of manufacturing and services. This is why infrastructure development is so important.

However, do not forget that infrastructure investment started from a relatively low level, which was about Rp 200 trillion in 2015. It is very small compared to household consumption which reaches approximately Rp 6.5 quadrillion or 55 percent of the total national economy. So, even if infrastructure investment increases by 50 percent, the immediate impact is still smaller than if consumption rises only by 5 percent. Therefore, if indeed we now focus on building infrastructure, economic growth in the range of 4.9 percent is actually still very reasonable.

Immediate policies directed at boosting short-term economic growth, such as intervention in a particular industry, have to be really thought out in regard to their impact. The reduction of interest rates and any monetary easing cannot necessarily be relied upon as a panacea. Credit growth will not increase if its need has not really recovered and particular industries are still experiencing contractions. When those who are encouraged to receive credit are the non-productive or speculative sectors, we must be vigilant to the danger of a bubble and bad debts at a later date.

Patience and consistence
Conceptually, major factors which could contribute to sustainable economic growth are knowledge and competitiveness. Therefore, the focus of the policies should be on structural problems such as infrastructure development and human resources, as well as the revamping of regulations that inhibit business competition. Many initiatives for the last one-and-a-half years are already on target, but patience is required as the benefits will only be felt three, five or even 10 years later.

In relation to declining short-term employment growth, here, additional social mitigations are needed aside from "breakthrough" ideas if they are available. If the employment growth of the formal sector is not adequate to accommodate the workforce, growth in the informal sector has to be facilitated and even be assisted to improve its productivity, for example, by encouraging the use of information technology (the informal sector here has a positive connotation, referring to the urban transport sector, retail trade, etc.).

Amid the uncertain condition of the world economy, there seems to be no shortcuts to prosperity. What exists is just a long way that must be passed in order for development to be sustainable and not intermittently be in crisis. We have been on the right track but we just have to be patient and consistent.

by Helmi Amran
source Kompas, Wednesday, June 29, 2016